RELIABILITY UPDATE FOR SN100C
This report is the second of a five part series highlighting
the results of recent reliability testing comparing the Nihon
Superior SN100C nickel stabilized tin/copper alloy to tin/lead
and SAC alloys. The full report is available by contacting
Jim Wertin at jwertin@fctassembly.com.
One of the primary concerns in the industry today is whether
converting to a lead free process from tin/lead will have an
impact on the reliability of the assembly. Much testing has
been performed in the last 10 years on lead free joints in
anticipation of the potential switch by the industry but there
are still concerns about the applicability of the results.
Most of the testing has been to procedures developed over time
for tin/lead alloys and the issue is whether there will be
the same correlation between test results and actual product
life cycle of lead free products in the field. As reliability
is a complex issue, and not just thermal cycling, a number
of tests were performed to attempt to simulate the environment
in use.
The testing included vibration, thermal shock, HALT testing,
salt fog, temperature/humidity, thermal cycling at multiple
ranges, hand solder repair with mixed alloys and thermal cycling.
HALT testing results will be discussed in this report. The
HALT testing was performed by Raytheon Company and is a combined
environmental test, which included both thermal cycling and
vibration. The thermal cycle was -55°C to 125°C at
20°C per minute ramp with dwells at the upper and lower
temperatures of 15 minutes. The boards were exposed to vibration
at the upper and lower dwells of 10 Grms increasing 5 G’s
after every 50 cycles to a maximum of 55 Grms (see profile
below).

Test results indicated the PDIP’s were
one of the more reliable components on board in this test.
The SN63, SN100C and SAC joints in the manufactured boards
had similar failures as indicated in the chart below. The repaired
assemblies displayed a large difference with the SAC assemblies
having 8 failures and the 63/37 and SN100C having 2 and 3 respectively.
The results were tabulated (see Table 1).

SN100C has been patented by Nihon Superior and is offered
worldwide through licensed manufacturers including FCT Solder
for North America. We offer SN100C for wave solder and lead
tinning, reflow solder paste applications, and SN100CL for
lead free hot air solder leveling (HASL) of P.C. Boards.
We will be including in future newsletters, many of the advantages
our current customers have discovered in switching to SN100C
as their lead free alloy of choice and we welcome your comments
and questions. We look forward to working with you to make
your transition to lead free as successful as possible.
SN100C has been patented by Nihon Superior and is offered
worldwide through licensed manufacturers including FCT Solder
for North America. We offer SN100C for wave solder and lead
tinning, reflow solder paste applications, and SN100CL for
lead free hot air solder leveling (HASL) of P.C. Boards.
We will be including in future newsletters, many of the advantages
our current customers have discovered in switching to SN100C
as their lead free alloy of choice and we welcome your comments
and questions. We look forward to working with you to make
your transition to lead free as successful as possible.
Table 1
MANUFACTURED BOARDS FAILED COMPONENTS BY ALLOY

REPAIRED BOARDS FAILED COMPONENTS BY ALLOY

|